Supporting someone with a mental health condition return or remain at work

 

Linda Sheahan:

                

Hello, and welcome to this webcast about supporting somebody at work with a mental health condition. My name is Linda Sheahan, Workplace Engagement Manager for Beyond Blue and I'm joined today by three panellists; Jo Farmer, giving an employee perspective, Steve Schubert, giving an employer perspective, and Dr Grant Blashki, Clinical Lead at Beyond Blue and mental health expert.

 
  To start with, on behalf of the panel, I'd like to acknowledge the traditional owners of the land on which we meet, the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin nation, and pay our respect to elders past, present, and emerging. As this video will have national reach, we extend our respect to elders and aboriginal, and Torres Strait islander peoples across Australia

 
  So, as a society, we're increasingly coming to understand just how common mental health conditions are. It's estimated that one in five in the Australian working population are likely to experience a mental health condition in any given year and almost 50% of us will experience a mental health condition over our lifetime. There's strong evidence that good work can have significant health benefits to people with a mental health condition. It's also good for business. There's an estimated average return on investment, $2.30 for every dollar invested in effective workplace mental health programs.
 
   

Through Beyond Blue's engagement with workplaces, we know there's strong interest from the community to better understand how to support people at work with a mental health condition. Our goal today is to unpack this topic and provide you with practical insights and strategies. So, to our panel. To set the scene, I'd like to introduce our panellists to talk about themselves a bit more and share their range of experience with mental health in the workplace. To start with, Jo.

 

Jo Farmer:

Hi, my name's Jo Farmer, and professionally I work as an Evaluation and Policy Consultant. I've also lived with a number of mental health conditions since I was a teenager. Most of the time I'm well, but there have been times in my life where I've needed just an extra bit of support to stay at work, and that's what I hope to talk about today.
 

Dr Grant Blashki:

I'm Grant Blashki, I'm a GP, I'm Lead Clinical Advisor for Beyond Blue. Very excited to be part of this webcast. As a GP, you sit there, you see many patients who are having mental health issues and it's always a bit more complicated to work out how they navigate the issues of work. Work can be really helpful, sometimes it can be part of the problem. So it sort of varies. So, really excited to be part of this important webcast.
 

Steve Schubert:

My name's Steve Schubert. The last 40 years I've been managing people in teams and as individuals in small businesses, medium businesses and large companies. Over that period, I've worked with people who have been challenged in the workplace and in recent times, it's easier to understand and have discussions with people that some of the root causes may be to do with mental health conditions. In the old days though, unfortunately these things often went undisclosed, or undiagnosed. So it's good to be working in an environment where we can talk about these things more openly.
 

Linda Sheahan:

Fantastic. So, to set the scene, maybe Jo and Grant, you could talk us through; what are some of the best practice goals, what are some of the things that we're aiming for to really support an employee, and keep them at work, and keep them healthy, what are we aiming for?
 

Dr Grant Blashki:

Well, I think when someone's experienced a mental health issue, and as we've heard from, Linda, it’s really common, the whole concept of how work is going to be part of that is really critical and what I hope is that when we've worked well with someone and worked well with the workplace, that people get back to work. They get all that lovely satisfaction, that self-esteem, from being back in the workplace and hopefully, eventually, they can put any mental health concerns behind them or at least know how to manage them. So, to my mind, that's really the goal. When I've seen this work best, their doctor and the workplace, and the person who's going through the issue, work really well together, they get back to their work and it's really part of their recovery, and I think it's important to remember that.
 
:
Jo Farmer:

Yeah, and I think, it's also as much about returning to work when you've had a difficult time, there's also the element of staying at work and how work can really support everyone to be their most well and I think that's a really important part of the discussion as well, is that everybody's complex, everyone has different aspects of their personality and things in their personal life, and mental health is just one of those, and so when you have an employer that respects that and flexibly approaches that, it's better for everyone.
 

Linda Sheahan:

There's a term we hear sometimes, a ‘person-centric’ approach. What does that mean to you? How does that play out?
 

Jo Farmer:

For me it's really about recognising, as I just mentioned, that everyone is their own person with multiple different things happening in their life and I think a person-centred approach really recognises what that person needs at that particular moment in their mental health journey. Whether they're having a tough time, or whether they need the support to stay well, or become well again and it's really about recognising what that individual needs at that moment.         
 

Dr Grant Blashki:

Yeah, I'd agree with that and I think also part of the person-centred approach, is realising that everyone is incredibly different, and they've got a different past background, perhaps of mental health issues, physical issues, a different unique workplace, what their job is, what are all the issues that they need to deal with. So it's a very much a tailored approach for that particular individual.

 

Linda Sheahan:

So, moving to the employer perspective, Steve, can you maybe talk us through some of the common examples of where employers are looking for help and what are some common things you've seen pop up?

Steve Schubert:
 
Sure. Well, I'm really glad to hear that some of the things we've been doing intuitively are backed up by clinical science. Because we struggle as a small employer to be sure we're doing the right thing for our people. We care, but we're not experts in this so we are operating a little bit by trial and error. So, intuitively we felt that it would be useful for someone to stay in the workforce where they're doing work that they're familiar with, they're in a familiar surrounding, they're being supported by people who they know and trust and care about them. But equally, we were conscious that often workplaces create stress. So we were concerned that perhaps having them in the workplace may be exacerbating their problem. So, it's good to hear that in general having some connection with the workplace is probably a good thing. But we really did struggle with this. We felt we weren't sure who we should be talking to. In the cases I've dealt with, we were very lucky that the individuals felt that they could trust us enough to disclose that they had a mental health problem and that really helped us frame our responses and to work constructively with them. But, we were also conscious that we could only see part of the picture. We didn't realise that we could talk to the employee, and perhaps get permission for them for us to speak to their doctors. In some cases we know that the families were probably a bit anxious about things that we were doing in the workplace, because they're at home, the person's at work with us, they don't see what's going on, they think we're probably putting more stress on the person. So there's a bit of an unhealthy dynamic there. It would have been good for us to be able to deal with that in some shape or form.
 

Linda Sheahan:

You sort of touch on there about information and access to information in order to help your employee with that recovery at work process. Jo and Grant, can you maybe give us some examples of what sort of information can and should be shared with an employer to help build trust and facilitate someone's recovery, maybe start with Jo?
 

Jo Farmer: 

Yeah, so I think the most useful information, and you might have some perspective on this too, [Steve], is really that functional information. So, what does my mental health condition mean for you as my employer? Not necessarily the ins and outs of what is my diagnosis, and what the cause of that, but really, how does that impact what I'm doing at work. So some of the things that I've disclosed previously are, the commute on my way to work is something that can cause me particular anxiety. So that's a functional impediment to me getting to work on time when obviously I want to get to work on time and so how can I work with my employer. In that case, we shifted my working hours slightly so that I avoided the peak times. But it was really about the functional component of the issue that allowed us to work through that to come up with an adjustment that was going to work for me. So that's certainly what I would put at the centre.
 

Dr Grant Blashki:

Yeah, I think it's one of those really delicate issues where there's not one size that fits all. Because when you think about it, you've got the individual there, they're in their own particular workplace and I think overshadowing the whole thing, or the important thing to think about, are privacy, and trust, and there's great variation between different workplaces. So, I don't know that there's one size that fits all, but some of the best examples that I've seen is where the patient, the person, feels they can trust their doctor, feels they've got a contact at the employer, who they can trust. I'm very aware that employers are trying to run a business as well and so they're juggling a lot of things. But if there's a trusted sensible person there, that might be their boss, it might be, in some of the bigger places, like a rehab/return to work person, which is ideal. I think the sorts of information, I really agree with Jo, that the private, intimate details of someone's life that might be in a medical record, they don't need to be shared with everyone. But I think the really critical issues are function. Can they do their job? Is that a reasonable job for them to do? How much flexibility can there be? So I really like that idea of focusing on function.
 

Jo Farmer:

I completely agree with you that trust is really at the heart of this. Again, it goes back to the idea of respecting people for their whole selves. When you have those strong relationships between a manager, or an HR team, and the employees doing the work, that's really where you're going to get the best outcomes when it's all about the relationship.
 

Linda Sheahan:

Steve, do you have any examples from your workplace where you've tried to support someone in a return to work scenario and we can work through an example maybe?
 

Steve Schubert:

I've worked with quite a few cases over the years. I've had situations where the person was clearly unable to work for a period of time, so we arranged for some form of leave so that they can stay away from the workplace for a period of time to aid their recovery. But at some point they wanted to come back to work, and we wanted them to come back to work, so we had to adjust their workload. So one of the things we tried, it's a pretty obvious one I guess, is perhaps starting with shorter working hours. So maybe they come in at 10:00, and leave at 4:00. One of the things that their team was very vigilant about, this person often worked very long hours, so the team was very vigilant around saying, “Okay, 4:00, time to go home. Leave that. I'll pick up what you're doing. Just do a quick handover so I know where it's up to.”, because otherwise the person, you know, 4:00 becomes 4:30, becomes 5:00, next thing they're working until 7:00 at night and you know that's not in their interest right at this point in time. So, I think having a supportive team really helps. Having a sense of, what are the trigger points, to your point, Jo, every situation is different. And you've got some personal things that can trigger it, whether it's a commute, or whether it's having someone dropping a lot of work on you at your desk and saying, “I need this by 5:00”, it really is good to understand, without being an expert in the person's condition, what are those trigger points that might exacerbate it, what are the things that you can do to ease the burden.
 
 
Jo Farmer: 

One of the things I found really helpful for doing that is writing that down in a Wellbeing Plan that's really clear about what are the things that keep me well, and what are the things that trigger me to have difficulties. And to go to the point about what we tell people, that then allows me to share that documented plan with the people that I want to know that information about me. So, with my Wellbeing Plan, I've shared it with my line manager, who it’s obviously very useful for them to understand what I need and what will support me to be well at work. But then also those trusted colleagues, the work wives, work husbands, who it's good for them to know where I'm at, and what are the things that make me well, or make me less well. That's a really proactive way I've found to help monitor my mental health and also force me to think about those things, what are the things that trigger me at work. Because it might be a cliché, but it's really when you know yourself well that you're able to keep yourself really well.
 

Linda Sheahan:

Can you maybe give us another example of the sort of information that might be in a Wellbeing Plan?
 

Jo Farmer:

So, some of the things that are in mine are really about the things that I can do to get myself feeling better when I start to feel myself slip so that the focus of my Wellbeing Plan is, it's different from a return to work plan, because it's really not getting me out of a crisis, but it's helping me stay well. So, mine says things like, when I'm feeling a bit down, or a bit anxious, it's about reaching out to supportive people, it's about going to the gym, it's about having a healthy dinner, getting a good night's sleep. All of those things that are not rocket science but they definitely are the things that help turn an average day around into a good one that's going to get me doing my best at work.
 

Linda Sheahan:
 
There's a point Steve touched on as well, and that was around having these conversations in the workplace. What sort of process or tools can an employee use around making decisions, around disclosure, in terms of, we're presuming trust to some extent. How can you make that decision, because I imagine not every workplace out there is necessarily the sort of environment where people may want to disclose.
 

Dr Grant Blashki:

Yeah. So, sitting in general practice, you see many people come in with mental health issues and their workplaces are very varied. At one end you might have an active bullying or discrimination issue going on, not as rare as you might think, unfortunately, and that's a central part of their upset and their distress. And at the other end, particularly in Beyond Blue, I've gone out and seen some wonderful workplaces that have really put the effort in to being a mentally healthy workplace, and they speak openly about it, and they train their managers, and everything in between, right. So, often there comes a point of conversation with the person to say, "Well listen, is there someone at work you want to talk to this about, or not?", and clearly if they're in an active conflict in a not very friendly workplace, they might say, "Listen, the last thing I do is going to disclose.". I was really pleased to see on the Beyond Blue Heads Up website, that there's a tool, where people can actually work through the decision making whether to disclose or not. Really useful thing, raises all the issues and I think it does need a bit of careful thought. I don't think there is one bit of advice for every patient and sometimes the best answer is, "No, look, we're not going to be explicit in this case." but hopefully where we're heading is where there's a much more open conversation.

 

Jo Farmer:

And also who to disclose to. You don't have to tell everyone, everything. Often it's just, there's a couple of people who need to know something because they're directly impacted or they're going to be the best support to you. So they're the ones that you can tell, even if the whole culture is not one that is going to support you
 

Steve Schubert:

That's very important, Jo, because often the first observable symptoms of a mental health problem in the workplace, is your colleagues start to notice, you're perhaps not as reliable as you used to be, there may be some absenteeism, or coming into work late, or just missing deadlines. The problem is that can get a life of its own. So all of a sudden people are gossiping and speculating, "So and so has kind of lost the plot." and "They're not working very well." and "I'm having to do all their work for them." etc. etc. so you really need to have someone in the workplace who understands what's causing this problem, that it's not because you don't care, it's not because you're lazy, it's not because your incompetent, it's because you have a mental health problem. And have someone in the workplace who can support you through that and kind of provide a bit of cover for you. Obviously, the further it can be disclosed, the easier it makes that. But you've got to have someone in your corner who's thinking about, “Well why are these problems occurring and how can I tell other people to back off and just take it a little bit easier on the person for a while?”.
 

Dr Grant Blashki:
 
Such a good point and I’ve been chatting to Steve, and one of the key issues I've found, that for employers, it's a bit of a tough gig sometimes to work out what's a performance issue, and what's a mental health issue, and where's the line, and how do you unpack that. I think that's a really important distinction.
 

Linda Sheahan: 

Actually, Steve, there was story you told us earlier today, which is a common thing we see at Beyond Blue, around we've moved so far in terms of wanting to support each other, but there's still that reluctance often to either recognise a condition within oneself, or that fear of disclosure. Are there any examples from your workplace you might be able to share that you've had employees in that situation?
 

Steve Schubert:
 
So, it still troubles me that in our modern era, where we think we're enlightened people, that there's a big difference between the fear of stigma that's associated with mental health, compared with a physical condition. So, if someone in the workplace, for example, gets cancer, and needs to have chemo, and go to the doctor, etc. they'll pretty readily disclose that because there's no fear of stigma. They may not want it widely known, but that's usually because it's quite challenging for people to have people come up to you all day and say, "Oh, how are you feeling, are you okay?" and you get that sort of question asked 25 times a day, it can get you down a bit, so I can understand even people with physical illnesses wanting to be a little coy about how many people know. But with mental health, there's still this stigma that it will affect my career, people will not think as well of me, particularly if you’re in a job that involves some sort of intellectual capability, can I trust this person to continue with these important jobs because they've got a mental health problem. It's disturbing to me that those things still exist. I was also involved in a situation where the individual, at the height of their challenges, felt like the most logical thing to do when they recovered was to actually leave our workplace and get a job somewhere else. Because they felt that their career had been trashed and they didn't have anywhere to go anymore. I think that was very disappointing that they would feel that way. It certainly wasn't the case at the place I was working at the time. In fact, we were troubled that we felt changing jobs at a time when you're suffering from a mental health condition is probably the worst thing you could do, because they'd be leaving a pretty supportive environment, with people who they were friends with and trusted them, they were doing work which was familiar and within their competency. To leave that behind and go work in a new place, take on a new role, with new expectations, I knew intuitively, we're not doctors, but intuitively we felt that that was probably not a good thing for them, that it was all driven by this fear that there's some sort of stigma associated with having had disclosed a mental health condition.
 
 
Jo Farmer:
 
It's so hard, because I know when I've been at my most depressed, it really affects your sense of self, and what you're capable of doing. There's the stigma element, but there's also the genuine belief that you aren't that great at what you're doing in life. It can really turn you towards that view of thinking, “Well, I've ruined everything, so where do I go from here?”. But I do remember having a conversation with a former manager of mine, and he said to me, when I was talking through what I needed at that point in time, he was like, "But Jo, what's the worst that's going to happen?" and I went, "Well, the worst that could happen is that I lose my job and I really don't want to do that." and he was just like, "There's no way you're going to lose your job because when you're functional and working at your best, you're a really great employee. And we know that, and we can see that, and this is just a temporary blip that you're working through." And it was that reassurance, was, it sounds like the employee that you're talking about was exactly the same, [Steve], but that reassurance at that point in time, that was exactly what I needed, to know that it was kind of all in my head, and that things weren't actually as bad as they seemed.
 
 
Linda Sheahan:
 
So , how can managers really, this is a two pronged question, how can you have that supportive conversation with an employee, to build trust in that moment, and also how might you have those conversations with the team to lead team attitudes to drive support. Steve?
 

Steve Schubert:
 

It's easier for me to talk about how you handle this as an individual manager. Jo made a really important point that sometimes the person is feeling a bit down on themselves and lacking in self-confidence. So you really do need to, this is not management science or anything, it's just being a human being. Sit down with the person and have a conversation with them, reassure them, try and rebuild their confidence. The bigger issue is with the team because as a manager, one of the frustrations is that you only see part of the puzzle. A mental health condition is rarely 100% to do with what's happening at work. We don't get to see what's happening with the family, we don't often get to talk to the medical practitioner, we don't know what the other factors are. But if that's a challenge for the individual manager, it's even more significant for the rest of the team. All they're seeing is bits and pieces, they're hearing stories, they're often impacted by the person's challenges at work, because they're having to pick up some of their duties, often at short notice. So, at some point, it's sitting down with the team and just being firm sometimes, and saying, "Look, we're going to help this person get through this. I realise it's going to put some pressure on the rest of you. I'm going to ask you, as your manager, to step up and help out in this situation, and help support this person." Again, if the person's taking time off because they're getting treatment, they've had a stroke, or they've got some disease, or they've got a cancer, everyone will pitch in and assume that it's the right thing to do. It's sometimes frustrating that it can be harder to get that support in a situation where the underlying problem is something that people have less understanding of. We all know what brain tumour, or leukaemia, or cancer can do to someone's body, but we don't fully understand how a mental health condition plays out so it makes it difficult for the team to understand.

 
 
Jo Farmer:
 
I think so much of what's coming through for me in a lot of the things that we've talked about, but particularly this issue, is that how you support an employee who needs to stay at or return to work is as much about what you do when that person's well. It's about all of the things that you do to create a supportive work environment, even when there's no particular reason to be a supportive work environment. It's about having the openness to have conversations about people as whole people, and not just widgets of resource doing their work. So that when something does come up, you've created this environment already where people can talk about their health and their wellbeing and their whole person. It's about things like, having flexible policies, about individual days, or about approaches to leave, so that when those resources need to be drawn on, because it's a difficult time, the benchmark's already been established, that that's just normal practice, that's how you work. The best experiences I've had in a workplace where I've needed support about a specific issue, have been the experiences that I've had in just the best workplaces that are good for me even when I'm well because they have really positive management cultures, and a lot of it's just basic HR. A lot of what you're saying there about just being a good person, it's not significantly difficult to do this kind of work if you just set those standards for you as an employer all of the time.
 
 
Linda Sheahan:
 
This is a little bit of a hard question, but if there's like two easy things an employer can do to show support practically, or just day to day, to keep the healthy, healthy, does anyone have a couple of just really practice short, sharp examples people could take away?
 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 
Well I might just mention, following on from Jo's point, is we know about what makes a mentally healthy workplace and some of it is actually is operational. It is about making sure that people have got the capacity to do the job that they've been given, that they've got the resources, they've got clarity about what they want to do. A lot of it comes in that leadership management that helps. A lot of the people that I see that have come unstuck, it's where they've got a monumental job that's beyond their capacity or hazy boundaries about what they're supposed to be doing or lack of tools, or the support. So I think that's all good business practice. Certainly we're seeing young people now are looking for jobs where they feel supported, and it's one of their top things that they look at in terms of retention. So, I think for employers there's every reason now to try and make good organisational management from a business point of view, from a mental health point of view as well.
 

Jo Farmer:

Yeah, I completely agree. I think it's that leadership, leadership on having the conversation, openness around mental health, that it's not a scary, stigmatising thing, it's a thing that happens to one in four of us. It's about having that leadership around flexibility, and diversity, and all of those things that we often hear talked about, but it's also about demonstrating that in action through having policies and genuinely having the conversations, and that kind of thing.
 

Linda Sheahan:
 
What about smaller businesses, so we're often talking, when we talk about job design and we're talking about support, I think often employers might feel like that's outside of their budget, or outside of the resources, or the expertise that they have internally. What about those sorts of organisations and what are some of the practical day to day tools or supports that might be out there to help them on their journey?
 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 
I'd just like to make a point. I think small businesses is a special case. There are extra pressures on small business owners. It's very hard for them to take time off. If someone's away for whatever reason, it's a small business, there's a percentage of the workforce, it's much bigger, particularly if there's like three of you, or whatever.
 
 
Linda Sheahan:
 
A third of your workforce gone.
 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 
They don't [say], "Oh, I'll just ring the OT rehab HR section, which would also be me.”, so I feel for our small business owners and I do think that they do have extra pressures. I was very excited to see that Beyond Blue's got its new Small Business Mental Health in the Workplace resource, which has got some fantastic tips for small business in particular. So a bit of a plug for that, I think it's really good.
 
 
Linda Sheahan:
 

I think that resource, it also includes the Wellbeing Plan that Jo spoke to, being a practical resource for small business owners and tailored to small business owners, to really remind them why they're in their role and some of their coping strategies to look after them going forward. So, one of the things, Steve, you sort of touched on, helping someone and increasing their hours gradually and I think Jo, you mentioned this also, I'd just like to go back to that return to work process and that recovery at work process. Practically, what are some of the tools and approaches we can do to help that, I think we've mentioned the Wellbeing Plan, but we also see return to work, or recover at work plans as well. Could we maybe go into that briefly?

 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 
I've found at the clinical end, if you're lucky enough to be dealing with an organisation that's got a skilled rehab OT/return to work person, they're gold, because they've done lots of these plans and they make a really thorough plan of how someone's going to go back to work. From the clinical end, keep in mind, the GPs are often pretty rushed, we're not necessarily trained in making return to work plans, so there is a little bit of adlibbing with that. A couple of general principles. I think with people, generally with mental health, but particularly in the workplace, I always say, "Let's manage expectations. You're not going to be back in two weeks. Let’s look at this as a project between now and Christmas." or, "This might be a few months." So, I think changing expectations, going back very gradually and also expecting a bit of up and downs, because that's what we see with mental health recovery. It might be two steps forward, then you have a really bad week. So, setting your expectations, that might be the case, that we're going to gradually get back, is really useful. And then the broader communication issues that we talked about. With consent, with the permission of the person, if you can get some sort of phone or face to face conversation with the employer, that's going to be much better. Because then people start to think creatively, and they go, "Oh, they can't do that job. But you know what, we really need someone to do this." or, "Actually, we could fill in part-time in this way." so suddenly everyone gets a bit more creative when you're actually dealing with a human being, than little bits of paper.
 
 
Linda Sheahan:
 
Is that discussion with the doctor, where the employee is agreeable, is that a conversation the employer can be a part of as well?
 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 
Well, definitely, we like that. We're tip toeing very carefully around respecting confidentiality and privacy, and as we talked before, there's a lot of intimate disclosure to the doctor. So, I think you need a pretty good discussion, certainly I find, with the patient, with the person, "What can we talk about" and usually, as we said before, I think the functional stuff is the most useful and most appropriate, than a whole detailed medical history, which is rarely needed.
 
 
Jo Farmer:
 

And that's where the creative stuff that you get to, in terms of solutions, comes from. The conversations that I've had with my managers around what can be done to adjust the way I'm working, come from those really functional, nitty gritty, “This is what I really struggle to do.” and so one of the things that I really struggled, when I was experiencing depression, my concentration was all over the place. I'd struggle to just sit at my computer for 30 to 40 minutes, which given that most of my job is spent hunched over a computer, was a real challenge for me and so we worked out some solutions to put in kind of checkpoints, so that at a certain point, I could go and take a break, and clear my mind, and come back and that was okay. And my employer wasn't seeing me as being constantly distracted, but actually seeing that what I was doing was refocusing. So, again, focusing on the strengths, positive approach and that only came through being able to have those functional conversations and I'm sure what have been even more valuable if my doctor had been involved.

 
 
Steve Schubert:
 
As an employer, I completely understand the privacy issue. But, information is gold and particularly if someone is returning to work, you're kind of anxious, are you pushing them too far, and in my experience the actual individual is probably not always the best judge of that. And you get this often stoicism that's particularly associated with men, "Oh, I'm fine." So you check in with them during the day, "How are you coping?", "Oh, no, all good, all good.", whereas in fact, they're not, so having some ability to get some tips and tricks around, “Well what are the signs to look for? How can I be confident the person is actually tracking well? What are the warning signs that they're not?”, all those sorts of things and having a better understanding of, how the condition will manifest itself without getting into all the gory details is useful. But there's definitely a trust issue there, and a disclosure issue, and often you have to rely on the individual disclosing what they're comfortable to disclose.
 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 

I think that discussion can be really useful around, what are the warning signs to look out for. So, uncharacteristic behaviours, sometimes getting a bit angry uncharacteristically, or withdrawing. The other one we haven't mentioned, which is not uncommon, are drug and alcohol issues, which always is complex when it overloads with mental health issues and how that works. Non-attendance, presenteeism, where they're sort of there but they're not really. So, there are a few little warning signs, and I guess from a clinical perspective, we're often looking at these as, relapse signatures, is what we call it. Saying, "Listen, if you haven't slept for three nights, this is bad." Or, "If you're back at the pub, that's not good." or, "If you're fighting with people at work again, that's not good.", so we try and identify what people's particular relapse signature is and it can be tricky. I think it's easy to have a really clear cut, linear version of what goes on, but as we know, people are messy, people are tricky, and if you're lucky enough to get an employer who's got that, as you said, capacity to be human, as well as a manager, that's really helpful.

 
 
Linda Sheahan:
 
Also that's where those functional plans, like a recovery at work plan, or a Wellbeing Plan, can be incredibly powerful, in that you've documented functional capacities, what are signs, and ideally you've got that written agreement between the doctor and the employee, that you can take to the employer. Then it helps, I think, with that trust and transparency piece as well. Particularly if you've got employees who might be newer to your business, or young, and they haven't had the chance to build that trust with you. So, I think trying to structure in some of those evidence based tools, to really build trust, build transparency and build a recovery journey, can be incredible powerful.
 
 
Jo Farmer:

I think it would be really useful for me as the employee as well. Because it's often one of the concerns that you have, is that, “I don't have the trust with my employer and I know I can do this job if my brain is doing what it needs to do.” and so having that all documented also would provide me with the support and knowledge to go with more than just my gut that I can do the job and have the evidence to back that up. So, I think it's great for everyone and it helps with that confidence piece that we were talking about before, that often an employee lacks. They can really assert themselves around that plan.

 

Dr Grant Blashki:
 
I can throw in there as well, Beyond Blue did some work around stigma and generally, people are more, they assume other people are more judgemental than they are. Do you know what I mean? If you're going through a mental health issue, it might be depression, it might be anxiety, your assessment of what everyone else is thinking, may well be wrong and exaggerated. Generally, people are a lot more forgiving and supportive and less judgemental and that's what our research has shown as well and that's a really good message, I think, around that.
 
 
Linda Sheahan:

I think Grant's speaking to some recent research Beyond Blue did. We recently surveyed over 20,000 police and emergency services workers. That report released last year found that the majority of employees wanted to support a colleague with a mental health condition, and I think it was as low 2%, felt that another [employee] would be a burden. So, there's really good evidence out there, that whilst self-stigma can be a real barrier to seeking help and speaking out. So, maybe just, we're sort of starting to run out of time. That self-stigma point, what are some of the challenges that can lead to, why does it matter and what can we do to help build that?
 

Jo Farmer:

I think because it's such a barrier to getting help and being honest with yourself and your employer around what you really need, and I certainly know as somebody who's quite ambitious and wants the most out of my career, it can be really challenging to admit to myself that I might need a little bit of extra help or I might need to step back. Like, one of the biggest changes in my life was deciding I only want to work four days a week, because I need that extra day in my week to look after myself, and to make sure I go to the gym, and to plan my meals for the week, and all those physical health things that are actually the things that help keep me mentally well. It's really hard when you have this mess of ambition and self-stigma, and it's a barrier to having a really honest conversation with yourself about what you want out of your career. Because it prevents you from seeking help and guidance from the other people who are going to be able to give you that kind of advice, which is, medically, your GP, and professionally, your manager, who can really help give you a different perspective on yourself and what you want.
 

Linda Sheahan:

Why is early help seeking important?
 

Jo Farmer: 


Because that's how you get better. I've been really lucky that I've spent a long time dealing with mental health conditions, so I've got quite good at identifying the triggers, and have a Wellbeing Plan, so I've got them written down. But it means that when I do start to notice myself tipping over the edge of what could be a cliff, I can stop myself going any further, which means that luckily, we've talked about returning to work, but I've actually never needed a return to work plan because I've got to the stage where I can identify when things are going off the rails and can put that early intervention into place, have those conversations that I need to have, so that I can stay at work. And that helps me get better because work gives you so much strength as well. You see people there, you have human connection, you get a sense of meaning, and we know that all of those things are really good for a recovery. So it's early intervention that enables that to happen.

 
 
Dr Grant Blashki:
 
I totally agree. Early is obviously better. As a GP, we're trying to detect and manage everything early, that's our whole preventive strategy. But I think with mental health in particular, the earlier you get in, and people I've looked after for many years, they know their signs, they know when the wheel's getting a bit wobbly, they know when to put everything into action. The only other thing I just wanted to say is, one way of framing this, which doesn't get talked about enough, is for an employer, like having someone who's been through a mental health issue, has had some mental health issues, it can be quite a positive. In general, not always, but there's a certain sensitivity and compassion, and they've been through something hard, it's a real plus. So, they actually bring quite a different perspective, I find, to the organisation. It's a bit of a generalisation, but I guess what I'm saying, it's not all deficiency, like it is a certain sensitivity that people who've been through a mental health issue actually bring to an organisation.
 
 
Jo Farmer:
 
I definitely think that having a mental health condition, while it's definitely given me some of the worst times in my life, it's also one of the best things that's happened, because it has given me that outlook on life. It's taught me incredible resilience, which I think, as an employee, is incredibly valuable, because I know everyone has stress in their job, whether they have mental illness or not, but being able to be resilient to that stress, is a really valuable thing, which I'm sure my employers get benefit from, as well as me.
 

Linda Sheahan:
 
There's a lovely term I've heard, ‘battle hardened’, and it's this experience and strength that it can give you and also I think the trust that it can actually build in your workplace can be incredibly powerful and valuable as an employer. So, as we wrap up, are there any last key tools or takeaways we can share with the audience today?
 
 
Steve Schubert:
 

I'll start from [an] employer point of view. I get, as Grant said, for small businesses it's quite challenging, finding the resources, but early disclosure and early intervention is obviously key. So, creating a workplace environment where people feel comfortable coming forward and feel like they can have those honest conversations with you is really critical. The other thing to finish on, what I didn't disclose, is I'm an actuary by profession, so we're into stats and probabilities and I can tell you now, if you've got more than 10 or 15 people in your workplace, at any point and time there's going to be someone there who's going through a divorce, or has a serious physical illness, or has a gambling problem, or has a mental health condition. You may not know who they are, but I can bet you there's someone in the workplace who's confronting those things. So, the important thing as an employer is to create an environment where you can identify who those people are, because they self-disclose, and you can help them get back on track.

 

Dr Grant Blashki:
 
I'd just like to comment, it's really been lovely to meet Steve, and Jo, who I already knew. But, I think what we're seeing is that leadership, enlightened leadership now, people on boards, are understanding that the mental health issue is like, 25 years ago we’re worried about everyone's backs and necks, and where they're sitting on their computers, but the mental health issue is huge in terms of risk management for businesses now. I also think that that sort of leadership that allows a bit of vulnerability and open communication, is really the style going forward. So, I really wish those employers well as they transform into these new sorts of organisations.
 
 
Jo Farmer:
 
And I always think it goes back to where we started, when we were talking a lot about relationships and trust, when we began this conversation and I really think that is the most central thing. It's about treating all of your staff as complex people, with strengths, and sometimes struggles, and if you create an environment where everyone is supported, regardless of what those strengths and struggles are, then you're going to get the best out of your people. And anyone who is going through a struggle or a challenge, is going to be supported to get as well as they can be, as soon as possible.
 

Linda Sheahan:

Fantastic. So, I'd like to thank the panel today, Jo, Steve, and Grant. And for any more information I encourage you to visit our website, and follow us on social media. Thank you for joining us.